The inspiration behind this article has been the hue and cry against Indian tradition, which has, in some sense, been plain disgusting to me. People seem to be complaining about anything Indian. Corruption, roads, beggars, quality of life, all these young issues, and of course, that old grandma sitting in the corner of the room imposing herself on everybody around, yes, Indian tradition! It is no new thing that people have been complaining about her, but she has managed to trudge on slowly across the years, with lesser and lesser endorsers albeit.
So, let us start off with the purpose of a "man-created God" or a "supreme being". Well, I'd like to believe, in spite of the multiple other purposes such an idea served, the most important one was that of bringing something common for everyone to believe in. Well, let me tell here,that the idea of belief and the power of human thought, is something I hold as extremely potent. The prayers of a million can move a mountain, I believe. India, or rather, the composite landmass we today know as the sub-continent, was built on this idea of faith. Let us not forget, that humans, earlier to the idea of faith, were plain savages. That is the basic human nature, faith, and the rules it brought along with it, make human beings what they are. So, if we are ready to discard faith, we must be ready to discard anything that we bracket under principles of ethics today. Do not mistake me, I am not trying to say that rules and ethics were followed out of fear for a supreme power which everyone believed in, but am trying to say that, they were followed out of a belief, that more will be well, with a united society striving for a common end, working towards their common belief, than out of plain savage mentality.
Indian tradition is something that has evolved over centuries. It was one part of the world, where there wasn't an idea of a religion, though there was an idea of worship. There were small sects, and different gods (and why gods? That has an answer too, but that is for another post some other day), but the people were given the freedom of choice. A father could be a believer in Rama, while the son could smear himself in vibhuthi, and sing paeans of Shiva. Rama's court had rishis of all faiths (read philosophies, in those days there weren't faiths, only philosophies), one of the most notable being Rishi Jabali, who used to be a proponent of the philosophy of atheism (which only meant the rejection of deities, no one really rejected the inexplicable power of nature then). The bracketing of Indians into religions happened much later, in the time of the British. That is why Hind, and Hindustan (meaning "the land enclosed by the Indus/Sindhu" and not "land of the Hindus") came first, and Hindu came later. The idea is not to propogate the idea of Indian culture being the best culture around, but it is to say, that we are not that bad! The sad part of the entire argument, is what we look up to in all awe and wonder, a land, which does not have a faith for itself, and does not believe in anything. Anyone who believes in a power, at a point of ultimate wroth, is chancy of thrusting his rage on the power he believes in, and letting be, while someone who doesn't believe in anything whatsoever, thrusts his rage on the society, thereby only causing ill to its harmony. It is no wonder, that the country we are talking about, has the largest crime rate in the world, while we, though not so great on this account, are still lower in the tenth position.
Above all the arguments that exist and will continue to exist about ideas such as theism, culture et cetera, what is more saddening to see is that we Indians tend to bash up our culture, in favor of some other non-existent one. We refuse to look into the nuances of why there are rules, and try to follow them correctly so as to serve the purpose of why they are, rather we decide to abandon them, and later bash them up on forums and in public. And we call ourselves educated people, logically thinkers, what a shame! Well, let me remind you, it wasn't a fool who said, the grass is always greener on the other side, and we may all do well to keep in touch with our Indian roots, because there might come a day when we might want to get back in touch with them, and we wouldn't be able to!
So, let us start off with the purpose of a "man-created God" or a "supreme being". Well, I'd like to believe, in spite of the multiple other purposes such an idea served, the most important one was that of bringing something common for everyone to believe in. Well, let me tell here,that the idea of belief and the power of human thought, is something I hold as extremely potent. The prayers of a million can move a mountain, I believe. India, or rather, the composite landmass we today know as the sub-continent, was built on this idea of faith. Let us not forget, that humans, earlier to the idea of faith, were plain savages. That is the basic human nature, faith, and the rules it brought along with it, make human beings what they are. So, if we are ready to discard faith, we must be ready to discard anything that we bracket under principles of ethics today. Do not mistake me, I am not trying to say that rules and ethics were followed out of fear for a supreme power which everyone believed in, but am trying to say that, they were followed out of a belief, that more will be well, with a united society striving for a common end, working towards their common belief, than out of plain savage mentality.
Indian tradition is something that has evolved over centuries. It was one part of the world, where there wasn't an idea of a religion, though there was an idea of worship. There were small sects, and different gods (and why gods? That has an answer too, but that is for another post some other day), but the people were given the freedom of choice. A father could be a believer in Rama, while the son could smear himself in vibhuthi, and sing paeans of Shiva. Rama's court had rishis of all faiths (read philosophies, in those days there weren't faiths, only philosophies), one of the most notable being Rishi Jabali, who used to be a proponent of the philosophy of atheism (which only meant the rejection of deities, no one really rejected the inexplicable power of nature then). The bracketing of Indians into religions happened much later, in the time of the British. That is why Hind, and Hindustan (meaning "the land enclosed by the Indus/Sindhu" and not "land of the Hindus") came first, and Hindu came later. The idea is not to propogate the idea of Indian culture being the best culture around, but it is to say, that we are not that bad! The sad part of the entire argument, is what we look up to in all awe and wonder, a land, which does not have a faith for itself, and does not believe in anything. Anyone who believes in a power, at a point of ultimate wroth, is chancy of thrusting his rage on the power he believes in, and letting be, while someone who doesn't believe in anything whatsoever, thrusts his rage on the society, thereby only causing ill to its harmony. It is no wonder, that the country we are talking about, has the largest crime rate in the world, while we, though not so great on this account, are still lower in the tenth position.
Above all the arguments that exist and will continue to exist about ideas such as theism, culture et cetera, what is more saddening to see is that we Indians tend to bash up our culture, in favor of some other non-existent one. We refuse to look into the nuances of why there are rules, and try to follow them correctly so as to serve the purpose of why they are, rather we decide to abandon them, and later bash them up on forums and in public. And we call ourselves educated people, logically thinkers, what a shame! Well, let me remind you, it wasn't a fool who said, the grass is always greener on the other side, and we may all do well to keep in touch with our Indian roots, because there might come a day when we might want to get back in touch with them, and we wouldn't be able to!
2 comments:
I agree with most of what you said, but you are trying to mix too many things in one post. Starting off with culture, then theism, then religion. They are all linked, but their existence is independent of one another.
I thought about the mix part da! I realized they are all huge topics, and by mixing them, I wouldn't be doing justice to any of them. Nevertheless, I just tried!
As for the linking, and existence, I agree with all independent existence, but this post is more about lashing out at critics of all three as a package!
Post a Comment